A warrior comes to town to kill the eldest sibling witch as he did to the sisters' great-great-great-aunt; Phoebe has a premonition of Prue being stabbed.

A warlock appears to collect on a pact he made with the Halliwell sisters' mother that guaranteed him their powers in exchange for not killing her.

Brendan wants to become a priest to avoid fulfilling his destiny as an evil warlock that would complete the triangle of the Evil Charmed Ones with his brothers.

Prue is blackmailed by a reporter who sees her using her powers to save a kidnapped boy; Phoebe and Prue research the demons responsible.

Lilly investigates the strangling of a young woman in her apartment in 1969 thanks to some aggressive investigating from the victim's brother.

Lilly re-opens the investigation into a disabled teen's tragic death after newly-found drawings suggest that he may have been murdered.

Stillman's priest comes forward with crucial information regarding the unsolved kidnapping and subsequent murder of a nine-year-old boy in 1998.

The 1984 case of a slain Philadelphia woman is reopened after her unique ring is found amongst the possessions of a dead drug addict.

Lily and her team re-investigate the circumstances surrounding a young alcoholic woman who died from hypothermia outside of a bar in 1995.

Jeffries seeks closure for a haunting childhood incident by asking Lilly to re-open the 1963 case of a black youth found beaten to death in the schoolyard.